CARDSPEED - Card Readers and Memory Cards

Test Details for Reader
Hama 19 in 1 V.2 SAMPLE

Brand:  Hama
Model:  USB 2.0 Card Reader 19 in 1
Info:  00055114 V.2

Note: These test results are taken from a pre-series sample. The PCB has a lot of manually soldered additional components and seems to have some problems with the higher clock frequencies of the latest cards (50MHz SD, 52MHz MMC 4.x and 40MHz MS PRO).

Hama 19 in 1 V.2 SAMPLE c't h2benchwc't h2benchwhjreggel cardcheck 
H-GL819:9317 read [MB/s]access [ms]readwrite 
Cardmin.max.avg.min.max.avg.avg.
[MB/s]
150
kB/s
chkavg.
[MB/s]
150
kB/s
chkComment
Transcend CF 120x 8GB15.99 ~17.8517.350.60 ~4.121.1017.42118.9×OK12.5585.6×OK16 banks of 512MB
SanDisk CF Ultra II 2GB10.62 ~11.6011.410.68 ~13.6710.8010.9974.9×OK8.8560.4×OK 
Transcend CF 80x 4GB10.18 ~10.4210.340.60 ~4.341.8610.2870.1×OK10.4871.5×OK 
Transcend CF 45x 4GB7.88 ~8.067.930.74 ~3.841.347.9954.5×OK5.8439.8×OK 
RiData CF 52x 2GB6.77 ~6.856.830.74 ~3.841.406.8346.6×OK5.5738.0×OK 
Transcend CF 30x 1GB4.91 ~5.615.550.84 ~3.721.195.5137.6×OK4.6731.8×OK 
RiData CF 25x 512MB (1)4.87 ~4.954.930.85 ~4.531.354.8833.3×OK2.8219.2×OK 
RiData CF 25x 512MB (2)4.88 ~4.954.930.87 ~4.051.354.8833.3×OK2.9520.1×OK 
Transcend CF 25x 512MB (1)4.87 ~4.954.920.86 ~3.841.354.8833.3×OK2.8819.6×OK 
Transcend CF 25x 512MB (2)4.85 ~4.944.910.86 ~3.931.354.8833.3×OK2.9820.3×OK 
Lexar CF 8x 16MB (2) 2177A4.29 ~4.434.410.62 ~3.220.754.3729.8×OK1.308.8×OK 
SanDisk CF 16MB (2002)1.92 ~1.951.942.01 ~4.732.131.9513.2×OK0.875.9×OK 
Toshiba 1.8" HD 5GB5.04 ~8.707.666.49 ~38.3721.347.1949.0×OK7.9454.1×OK 
Hitachi MD 4GB (MuVo²)3.83 ~6.945.283.09 ~42.3720.405.3136.2×OK2.1914.9×OK 
IBM MD 1GB2.46 ~4.313.555.37 ~36.6221.603.5624.2×OK1.8112.3×OK 
Cardreadacc.readwriteComment
SONY MS PRO Duo 2GB9.71 ~10.8910.840.63 ~3.330.9410.8273.8×OK9.6265.6×OK 
SONY MS PRO Duo HS 1GB
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail8.6859.2×OKVery low read rate
SONY MS PRO 256MB9.71 ~10.7410.660.62 ~3.220.7510.5572.0×OK7.9454.1×OK 
SONY MS Duo 32MB0.93 ~1.291.261.22 ~95.4860.881.278.6×OK1.127.6×OK 
Lexar Media MS 64MB1.01 ~1.381.351.22 ~98.4781.511.369.2×OK1.318.9×OK 
Cardreadacc.readwriteComment
Panasonic SD 2GB HS17.32 ~18.5418.461.08 ~4.101.5318.43125.8×OK12.3784.4×OK 
ATP Pro Max SD 512MB16.15 ~17.2417.160.51 ~5.010.91
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
FailFilesystem not recognized
Transcend SD 150x 4GB17.18 ~18.6618.500.59 ~3.350.8318.44125.9×Error11.9781.7×ErrorRandom errors
miniSD 1.1 512MB17.31 ~18.5318.450.61 ~501.381.0718.42125.7×Error11.2576.7×OKRead: Random bit errors
Unknown SD 256MB9.04 ~9.809.750.50 ~501.991.199.6866.1×OK0.604.0×OK 
Panasonic SD 512MB9.68 ~9.809.770.64 ~3.330.759.7666.6×OK6.0741.4×OK 
Transcend SD 45x 1GB6.49 ~7.477.370.62 ~6.371.457.3850.4×OK6.6245.1×OK 
RiData SD 45x 1GB4.42 ~5.435.390.98 ~57.4847.035.4036.8×OK3.1121.2×OK 
Hama miniSD 128MB7.10 ~7.817.770.60 ~3.340.767.7753.0×OK6.7646.1×OK 
TransFlash 128MB9.60 ~10.039.920.65 ~10.845.269.9768.0×OK2.0213.7×OK 
Cardreadacc.readwriteComment
Generic MMCplus 128MB9.57 ~10.4210.360.49 ~3.220.63
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
FailRead data gets scrambled
Generic MMCplus (2) 128MB9.86 ~10.6310.590.49 ~3.240.63
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
FailRead data gets scrambled
MMCmobile 128MB8.43 ~8.848.760.49 ~3.090.638.7859.9×OK7.6752.3×OK 
MMCmicro 256MB9.33 ~10.4110.370.48 ~3.090.63
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
FailFilesystem not recognized
Generic MMC 256MB1.63 ~1.661.660.99 ~4.071.421.6611.3×OK1.6211.0×OK 
Hama RS-MMC 128MB1.65 ~1.671.660.99 ~3.621.121.6711.3×OK1.6010.9×OK 
Cardreadacc.readwriteComment
xD Type H 1GB1.47 ~5.504.310.99 ~465.73451.194.3229.5×OK1.157.8×OK 
xD Type H 256MB1.86 ~6.295.190.98 ~465.62432.065.2235.6×OK0.734.9×OK 
xD Type M 2GB2.09 ~5.604.041.37 ~441.48434.904.0227.4×OK1.308.8×OK 
xD Type M 1GB1.21 ~3.052.521.60 ~439.86430.292.5317.2×OK1.339.0×OK 
xD Type M 256MB0.94 ~3.042.641.24 ~439.47411.772.6518.0×OK1.419.6×OK 
xD Type S 64MB1.81 ~5.815.040.87 ~447.01320.615.1234.9×OK1.097.4×OK 
SmartMedia 128MB3.76 ~6.576.060.74 ~165.84142.746.0841.4×OK1.248.4×OK 
SmartMedia 64MB3.81 ~6.576.150.70 ~164.97117.406.1942.2×OK1.137.7×OK 
PixoMedia SM 32MB (1)3.28 ~6.756.410.67 ~159.3568.886.4544.0×OK1.127.6×OK 
PixoMedia SM 32MB (2)3.24 ~6.666.360.67 ~159.2168.796.4043.7×OK1.157.8×OK 
PixoMedia SM 32MB (3)3.25 ~6.756.410.67 ~159.0968.796.4644.1×OK1.147.7×OK 
Olympus SM 32MB (1)3.28 ~6.676.360.67 ~158.0968.446.4143.7×OK0.855.7×OK 
Olympus SM 32MB (2)3.29 ~6.756.440.67 ~159.1268.716.4944.3×OK0.886.0×OK 
xD Type M 1GB, xD-SM
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
FailFilesystem not recognized
xD Type S 64MB, xD-SM3.36 ~5.885.540.67 ~173.46123.505.5738.0×OK1.157.8×OK 
xD Type S 16MB, xD-SM5.73 ~5.985.950.63 ~3.230.755.9540.6×OK0.916.2×OK 


Hans-Jürgen Reggel   ·   http://www.hjreggel.net/cardspeed/   ·   2004-02-28 ~ 2010-02-13