CARDSPEED - Card Readers and Memory Cards

Test Results, Detailed Comparison

Attention! These tables only show cards and readers up to January 2007.
For current test results, use the selection for  Card Type  or  Card Reader .
This is the Detailed Comparison of Selected Card Readers. There is also a  Quick Comparison  available.
The table headings link to the full test details of the respective card reader.

Test Results for Multi Cardreaders

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 PIXO MSR-PROHama 1000&1 Multi (9323)Hama MMS VSV-40 (1.07)C-enter 22 in 1 USB 2.0C-enter 12 in 1 AluminiumHama 22 in 1 55116 (1.8D)
 AU6375-0607H-GL819:9323PS2002OTi2126-0507GL816E:9138H-IC1210:1.8D
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
SanDisk CF Extreme IV 4GBCF-I17.8116.790.8017.7917.230.824.454.370.947.457.030.758.317.971.196.746.201.03
SanDisk CF Extreme III 1GBCF-I17.7717.160.8117.2617.580.934.424.341.067.417.010.818.287.971.306.736.161.08
Transcend CF 120x 8GBCF-I17.5312.441.0217.4012.491.11
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SanDisk CF Ultra II 2GBCF-I11.118.9610.7110.968.8410.804.283.9010.857.296.1210.688.207.0011.146.555.4210.96
Transcend CF 80x 4GBCF-I10.3810.711.8410.1710.451.874.284.121.997.556.601.747.216.822.246.385.762.10
Transcend CF 45x 4GBCF-I8.055.941.237.955.871.354.423.801.477.335.501.227.655.351.736.725.071.48
RiData CF 52x 2GBCF-I6.925.601.326.835.561.44
Fail
5.63
Fail
4.942.651.235.664.661.706.665.061.48
Transcend CF 30x 1GBCF-I5.524.701.115.534.701.195.584.571.194.782.601.074.974.151.555.404.371.32
Toshiba 1.8" HD 5GBPCMCIA-II HD7.607.9221.397.147.9621.42
 
 
21.63
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Hitachi MD 4GB (MuVo²)CF-II 1" MD5.332.1920.235.312.1820.263.312.1820.36
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SanDisk Extr. III SD 2GBSD 1.119.1317.730.8819.1517.840.86
 
 
 
7.447.930.849.387.811.22
 
 
 
Panasonic SD 2GB HSSD 1.118.4316.621.5618.4416.681.558.947.531.607.026.741.488.667.941.874.963.241.77
ATP Pro Max SD 512MBSD 1.117.1415.100.9117.1515.080.919.588.921.047.447.600.859.209.131.255.193.481.15
Transcend SD 150x 4GBSD 1.118.4611.720.8618.4412.030.869.779.030.997.447.740.759.389.051.165.063.531.07
Unknown SD 256MBSD9.758.590.989.748.560.978.437.461.057.447.100.918.147.521.315.193.381.21
Panasonic SD 512MBSD9.766.300.766.555.180.859.065.590.887.335.520.758.745.961.135.133.231.00
miniSD 1.1 512MBminiSD 1.118.4312.780.8818.4212.910.869.588.500.987.437.530.779.338.751.165.103.461.08
Hama miniSD 128MBminiSD7.776.840.776.015.300.877.436.480.887.426.800.757.196.661.134.783.301.00
microSD 128MBmicroSD10.416.941.0910.476.911.10
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
MMCplus 128MB (1)MMCplus10.359.110.6310.349.120.632.252.160.882.522.480.751.691.661.228.044.550.81
MMCmicro 256MBMMCmicro10.379.930.6310.369.850.632.252.190.882.522.520.751.691.671.258.054.690.87
Generic MMC 256MBMMC2.172.101.381.661.631.432.182.061.442.522.431.261.641.611.771.551.381.64
SanDisk MS PRO Duo X3 2GBMS PRO Duo16.0515.620.9716.038.330.915.606.381.036.304.780.876.135.271.596.165.151.10
SanDisk MS PRO Duo U2 4GBMS PRO Duo16.0410.251.0116.058.110.88
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SONY MS PRO Duo HS 1GBMS PRO Duo10.788.781.0610.767.100.945.641.731.065.861.530.946.541.801.576.141.481.19
SONY MS PRO 256MBMS PRO10.678.470.8610.656.720.755.632.550.885.862.150.756.532.701.384.521.871.12
SONY M2 256MBM28.273.100.89
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SONY MS Duo 32MBMS Duo1.531.2511.831.271.1261.910.990.9641.621.080.691.461.010.9686.811.161.0349.45
Lexar Media MS 64MBMS1.681.4911.531.361.3182.901.051.1283.261.170.781.521.081.10110.191.241.17102.19
SmartMedia 128MBSmartMedia6.901.5983.695.981.18145.306.361.74177.495.241.701.174.631.18219.033.821.08176.66
SmartMedia 64MBSmartMedia7.111.4468.636.111.12119.016.491.51112.155.241.471.074.901.14179.773.850.98113.76
xD Type M 2GBxD Type M5.692.1482.46
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
3.551.53192.53
xD Type H 1GBxD Type H5.641.50119.044.341.51454.74
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
3.631.22219.66
xD Type H 256MBxD Type H6.440.56111.235.251.87434.94
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
3.740.73200.21
xD Type M 1GBxD Type M3.032.1882.382.541.37431.932.142.32183.70
Fail
Fail
Fail
 
 
 
2.591.51190.21
xD Type M 256MBxD Type M3.082.1677.812.661.47413.33
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2.591.50173.64
xD Type S 64MBxD6.611.4581.265.161.06322.356.401.55112.554.831.511.08
n/a
n/a
n/a
3.841.02107.07
xD Type M 2GBxD Type M-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
xD Type H 1GBxD Type H-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
27.70
 
 
 
xD Type H 256MBxD Type H-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
262.29
 
 
 
xD Type M 1GBxD Type M-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
2.262.33183.66
Fail
Fail
Fail
 
 
28.212.601.50193.24
xD Type M 256MBxD Type M-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2.451.56231.13
 
 
 
xD Type S 64MBxD-SM
 
 
 
 
 
 
6.481.56111.764.841.511.074.491.18186.003.851.02108.49

Test Results for Compact Flash / Microdrive Readers

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 Hama USB 2.0 UDMA CFCompuApps USB UDMA CFCF Reader/WriterNEXTO CF ND-2500 1394aHama FireWire 800SanDisk Extr. FireWire 800
 xSil251-G:2.22xSil251-G:2.22AU6366-0604OXFW911OXFW912-0637OXFW912-0604
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
SanDisk CF Extreme IV 4GBCF-I30.9622.950.6830.9624.720.6818.4817.530.8114.9712.160.6240.3933.850.3940.4133.870.39
SanDisk CF Extreme III 1GBCF-I18.4817.510.8018.4817.500.8017.8417.980.8514.8812.400.6913.9112.500.4913.9012.480.49
Transcend CF 120x 8GBCF-I18.2012.620.9418.2012.610.9417.8012.601.0215.0410.430.87
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
SanDisk CF Ultra II 2GBCF-I11.258.9610.6411.258.9510.6511.138.9510.7112.508.5910.5112.478.8510.3512.498.8710.32
Transcend CF 80x 4GBCF-I10.5710.681.7410.4110.581.7510.4010.561.8611.2310.061.7211.2710.551.4311.1110.391.45
Transcend CF 45x 4GBCF-I
 
 
 
8.165.941.228.105.901.238.675.741.118.665.870.878.685.840.86
RiData CF 52x 2GBCF-I6.575.401.196.575.391.196.945.601.314.593.801.19
 
 
 
5.554.500.92
Transcend CF 30x 1GBCF-I5.374.621.065.394.591.065.564.691.124.293.631.014.894.180.754.894.190.75
Toshiba 1.8" HD 5GBPCMCIA-II HD
 
 
 
7.677.9421.22
 
 
 
8.157.6721.38
 
 
 
8.157.4921.19
Hitachi MD 4GB (MuVo²)CF-II 1" MD
 
 
 
5.332.1920.365.322.1820.575.292.1421.62
 
 
 
5.292.1421.26

 CF Reader/WriterA-Tec CFVivanco RW CFHama CardBus CFCardBus CF
 AU6366-0604GL813USB-0444GL813USB-0444VEN_1145-F021VEN_1145-F021
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
SanDisk CF Extreme IV 4GBCF-I18.4817.530.8111.1010.960.68
 
 
 
13.668.380.4512.848.180.45
SanDisk CF Extreme III 1GBCF-I17.8417.980.8510.8611.030.78
 
 
 
13.558.410.5612.768.200.53
Transcend CF 120x 8GBCF-I17.8012.601.0211.219.590.94
 
 
 
7.855.620.797.525.370.71
SanDisk CF Ultra II 2GBCF-I11.138.9510.7110.558.8110.6010.558.8010.616.584.5910.446.254.4210.77
Transcend CF 80x 4GBCF-I10.4010.561.8610.5110.331.7410.6210.321.747.705.621.577.385.351.55
Transcend CF 45x 4GBCF-I8.105.901.238.195.901.228.185.901.216.894.390.966.534.201.28
RiData CF 52x 2GBCF-I6.945.601.315.054.331.265.054.331.264.333.301.104.503.211.03
Transcend CF 30x 1GBCF-I5.564.691.124.644.171.064.624.171.064.083.300.874.453.210.83
Toshiba 1.8" HD 5GBPCMCIA-II HD
 
 
 
 
 
 
7.917.9621.178.217.5921.067.157.3521.27
Hitachi MD 4GB (MuVo²)CF-II 1" MD5.322.1820.575.322.1920.205.322.1820.145.322.1619.974.632.1820.31

Test Results for SD / MMC Card Readers

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 Hama 1000&1 Mobile V2Pretec e-Disk IILexxington SD / MMCVivanco RW SDSingim SG361 SD/MMCPanasonic CardBus SD
 H-GL819:9325AU63xxAU6369-0505RTS5106UB6220VEN_10F7-8F00
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
SanDisk Extr. III SD 2GBSD 1.119.1717.850.9218.4817.580.894.634.890.989.428.741.21
Fail
Fail
Fail
22.2012.650.96
Panasonic SD 2GB HSSD 1.118.4616.701.5918.4615.841.554.464.331.67
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
Fail
20.929.651.62
ATP Pro Max SD 512MBSD 1.117.1815.180.9117.1814.940.914.654.751.049.248.451.289.248.310.8519.4712.000.98
Transcend SD 150x 4GBSD 1.118.4711.910.8618.4811.450.864.654.810.989.428.481.23
Fail
Fail
Fail
21.839.990.91
Unknown SD 256MBSD9.648.520.989.718.530.974.674.561.108.047.121.298.607.590.8510.098.001.04
Panasonic SD 512MBSD6.565.190.889.786.320.784.604.150.888.755.321.138.915.920.6410.375.410.87
miniSD 1.1 512MBminiSD 1.118.4512.910.8818.4512.700.884.624.000.969.248.011.209.248.150.7521.6410.530.92
Hama miniSD 128MBminiSD6.085.320.877.716.820.764.414.240.887.116.141.12
 
 
 
7.886.390.90
microSD 128MBmicroSD10.426.931.1010.436.901.094.463.821.586.024.341.806.294.541.3310.736.311.19
MMCplus 128MB (1)MMCplus10.379.110.6310.379.120.631.571.581.002.232.141.139.588.030.501.451.391.03
MMCmicro 256MBMMCmicro10.389.890.6310.389.910.631.571.601.002.232.171.139.598.570.511.451.401.05
Generic MMC 256MBMMC1.661.621.471.771.731.381.511.511.512.152.031.651.661.611.321.411.351.57

Test Results for SD / MMC / Memory Stick Card Readers

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 Hama 1000&1 Mobile V2
 H-GL819:9325
 hjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/sms
SanDisk Extr. III SD 2GBSD 1.119.1717.850.92
Panasonic SD 2GB HSSD 1.118.4616.701.59
ATP Pro Max SD 512MBSD 1.117.1815.180.91
Transcend SD 150x 4GBSD 1.118.4711.910.86
Unknown SD 256MBSD9.648.520.98
Panasonic SD 512MBSD6.565.190.88
miniSD 1.1 512MBminiSD 1.118.4512.910.88
Hama miniSD 128MBminiSD6.085.320.87
microSD 128MBmicroSD10.426.931.10
MMCplus 128MB (1)MMCplus10.379.110.63
MMCmicro 256MBMMCmicro10.389.890.63
Generic MMC 256MBMMC1.661.621.47
SanDisk MS PRO Duo X3 2GBMS PRO Duo15.627.360.96
SanDisk MS PRO Duo U2 4GBMS PRO Duo15.667.220.92
SONY MS PRO Duo HS 1GBMS PRO Duo10.786.460.94
SONY MS PRO 256MBMS PRO10.696.410.75
SONY M2 256MBM2
 
 
 
SONY MS Duo 32MBMS Duo1.261.1264.55
Lexar Media MS 64MBMS1.341.3186.29

Test Results for Memory Stick Card Readers

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 Hama 1000&1 Mobile V2Heisei HR-201 MSLexxington MS / MS Pro
 H-GL819:9325RTS5106AU6369-0505
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
SanDisk MS PRO Duo X3 2GBMS PRO Duo15.627.360.9611.3311.200.975.495.290.97
SanDisk MS PRO Duo U2 4GBMS PRO Duo15.667.220.9211.258.811.005.475.181.00
SONY MS PRO Duo HS 1GBMS PRO Duo10.786.460.949.451.901.065.491.631.06
SONY MS PRO 256MBMS PRO10.696.410.759.442.960.885.482.360.87
SONY M2 256MBM2
 
 
 
7.912.961.005.412.521.00
SONY MS Duo 32MBMS Duo1.261.1264.551.371.161.381.091.0412.53
Lexar Media MS 64MBMS1.341.3186.291.461.3161.571.091.2012.43

Test Results for xD-Picture Card Readers

Multi-Reader  ·  CF/MD Reader  ·  SD/MMC Reader  ·  SD/MMC/MS Reader  ·  MS Reader  ·  xD Reader

 Lexxington xD JQXD-2MAUSB-300
 SSK-A46515-2M5635A1-0443
 hjreggelh2bhjreggelh2b
 readwriteacc.readwriteacc.
 MB/sMB/smsMB/sMB/sms
xD Type M 2GBxD Type M3.791.74153.873.871.63626.63
xD Type H 1GBxD Type H4.121.44189.834.001.38323.07
xD Type H 256MBxD Type H4.490.84179.314.330.82282.45
xD Type M 1GBxD Type M2.681.90152.762.261.60930.94
xD Type M 256MBxD Type M2.781.90145.382.281.57832.93
xD Type S 64MBxD4.761.25133.944.551.16133.30


Hans-Jürgen Reggel   ·   http://www.hjreggel.net/cardspeed/   ·   2004-02-28 ~ 2007-11-07